|Year : 2011 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 26-29
Clonidine versus tramadol for post spinal shivering during caesarean section: A randomized double blind clinical study
Velayudha S Reddy, Sunil Chiruvella
Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care, Rajeev Gandhi Institute of Medical Science, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh, India
|Date of Web Publication||25-Aug-2011|
Velayudha S Reddy
Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care, 2-827, Srihari Rao Street, Nagaraja Peta, Kadapa, Andhra Pradesh
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background : Control of post spinal shivering is essential for optimal perioperative care, which can be achieved either by oral or parental medications. The present study is designed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of intravenous low-dose clonidine and tramadol in the treatment of post spinal shivering.
Materials and Methods : In this prospective, a double blind, randomized study, 90 ASA grade I or II, parturients aged 18 - 35 years, undergoing caesarean section under spinal anaesthesia, who subsequently developed shivering grade 3 or 4, were randomized into two groups, to receive either clonidine or tramadol. The efficacy and response rate of the study drugs were evaluated and recorded. Side effects like, nausea, vomiting, hypotension, bradycardia, dry mouth, sedation, skin rash and headache, if present, were recorded. All data were analyzed by using the Chi square test and the Z-test.
Results : There were significant differences in the response rate between the drugs (P < 0.05). Time taken from the starting of treatment to cessation of shivering was significantly less with the tramadol group (P < 0.05), however, the frequency of nausea, vomiting, sedation and headache were also significantly more in the tramadol group
Conclusion : In our study we concluded that both clonidine and tramadol control shivering. However, the response rate was higher and time taken to control shivering was lesser with tramadol, but the response rate and the side effects were lesser with clonidine.
Keywords: Anaesthesia spinal, caesarean section, clonidine, shivering, tramadol
|How to cite this article:|
Reddy VS, Chiruvella S. Clonidine versus tramadol for post spinal shivering during caesarean section: A randomized double blind clinical study. J Obstet Anaesth Crit Care 2011;1:26-9
|How to cite this URL:|
Reddy VS, Chiruvella S. Clonidine versus tramadol for post spinal shivering during caesarean section: A randomized double blind clinical study. J Obstet Anaesth Crit Care [serial online] 2011 [cited 2019 May 21];1:26-9. Available from: http://www.joacc.com/text.asp?2011/1/1/26/84252
| Introduction|| |
Shivering is one of the most common complications of a central neuraxial blockade, due to impairment of thermoregulatory control.  An incidence of 57% of shivering during regional anaesthesia has been reported.  Shivering during a neuraxial block could have potentially detrimental effects and it may contribute to increased wound pain.  Various pharmacological and non-pharmacological  methods have been proposed, of which tramadol  and clonidine  are the recently used drugs to control shivering. This prospective, double blind, randomized clinical study was designed to compare the anti-shivering effects and side effects of clonidine and tramadol in the treatment of post spinal shivering.
| Materials and Methods|| |
After obtaining permission from the Institutional Ethics Committee and written informed consent from all parturients, 90 ASA grade I and II parturients, between the ages of 18 and 35 years, who subsequently developed shivering intraoperatively during elective or emergency caesarean section, under spinal anaesthesia, were enrolled by random allocation in this study and divided into two groups of 45 each. Parturients with known hypersensitivity to tramadol and clonidine, cardiopulmonary, liver, or renal disease, psychological disorders, hypo- or hyperthyroidism, a need for blood transfusion during surgery, an initial body temperature > 38°C or < 36°C, a known history of alcohol or drug abuse, those receiving vasodilators, those who received drugs for labor analgesia, or other medications likely to alter thermoregulation, were excluded from the study.
The parturients did not receive any premedication. On arrival into the operating room, an 18G venous cannula was inserted and preloading done with Ringer's Lactate solution at 10 ml kg -1 h -1 before insertion of spinal anaesthesia and reduced to 6 ml kg -1 h -1 after spinal anaesthesia. Volume of preloading intravenous fluids, use of mephenteramine for hypotension and the dose of local anaesthetic were determined by the attending anaesthesiologist and were not affected by enrollment in the study. All preloading fluids and drugs were stored and administered at room temperature.
Subarachnoid anaesthesia was instituted at the L 3 - L 4 spinal interspaces, with 0.5%, hyperbaric bupivacaine 10 mg (2 ml) using a 25G Quincke spinal needle. The parturients were randomly (envelope randomization) allocated to receive Clonidine 50 μg (Group-C, n = 45) or Tramadol 50 mg (Group-T, n = 45). Parturients who developed grade 3 or 4 shivering for at least three minutes after spinal anaesthesia were included in the study; both the drugs were given as slow i.v. bolus injections. The treatment drugs were diluted to a volume of 5 ml in a 5 ml syringe and presented as coded syringes by an anaesthesiologist who was blinded to the group allocation. Supplemental oxygen (5 liters min -1 ) was delivered via a facemask during the operation. All parturients were covered with one layer of surgical drapes over the chest, thighs and calves during the operation and one cotton blanket over the entire body after operation.
The presence of shivering was observed by an observer anaesthesiologist blinded to the administered study drug. Shivering was graded using a scale similar to that validated by Tsai and Chu  grade-0: No shivering; grade-1: Piloerection or peripheral vasoconstriction, but no visible shivering; grade-2: Muscular activity in only one muscle group; grade-3: Muscular activity in more than one muscle group, but not generalized; and grade-4, shivering involving the whole body. The anti-shivering effect of the study drug was assessed by both the parturient and observing anaesthesiologist. The parturients were asked to evaluate the effect of treatment, two minutes after injection as, no response, slight response, or marked response. This was then recorded as per the statement of the parturients. The attending anaesthesiologist independently assessed and recorded the time of cessation of shivering after treatment. Fifteen minutes after the administration of the study drug, if the shivering grade continued to be the same, the treatment was regarded as ineffective and i.v dexamethasone 5 mg was administered to control the shivering.
Heart rate, respiratory rate and peripheral oxygen saturation were monitored continuously, arterial blood pressure was recorded every two minutes, for first 30 minutes and every five minutes for additional 60 minutes using the standard non-invasive monitors, before and after intrathecal injections, till the development of shivering, as well as after administration of study drug. During the perioperative period, body temperatures (tympanic and axillary temperature) were recorded with an ear and an axillary thermometer. The ambient temperature was measured by a wall mounted thermometer. The ambient temperature was maintained at 24°C - 26 o C, with constant humidity.
Side-effects such as nausea, vomiting, hypotension, bradycardia, dry mouth, sedation, skin rash and headache, if present, were recorded. Hypotension was defined as a decrease in arterial pressure of more than 20%, in relation to a baseline pressure or systolic pressure of less than 100 mmHg. If patients developed nausea and vomiting, i.v. metoclopramide 10 mg was administered.
The attending anaesthesiologist also assessed the degree of sedation on a five-point scale: 1: Fully awake and oriented; 2: Drowsy; 3: Eyes closed, but rousable to command; 4: Eyes closed, but rousable to mild physical stimulation; and 5: Eyes closed but unarousable to mild physical stimulation.  All data were analyzed using the Chi squire test and Z-test
Previous studies have found an incidence of shivering of the order of 40 - 65%. We anticipated an incidence of 50%. Hence, we assumed that < 35 parturients were required in each group for a type I error of 0.05 and the power of the study was > 90%, a sample size of 45 was calculated. Statistical comparisons of patient characteristics and time taken to control shivering, between the groups, were performed using the Z-test. Nominal or categorical data, including the overall incidence of shivering, response rate and side effects between the groups were analyzed and compared using the chi square test. The value of P < 0.05 was considered as statistically significant.
| Results|| |
Ninety parturients experienced shivering of grades 3 and 4 after spinal anaesthesia, during the caesarean section. Parturients characteristics in respect of age, weight, body temperature and duration of surgery were similar between the groups [Table 1]. Response rate (shivering ceased after treatment within 15 minutes) was found to be 95.56% in the tramadol group and 86.67% in the clonidine group and the time required to cease shivering was shorter in the tramadol group than in the clonidine group [Table 2]. Nausea, vomiting, sedation and headache were more common in the tramadol group. No patient in any group developed hypotension or skin rash before or after treatment [Figure 1]. In addition the heart rate, respiratory rate and oxygen saturation were not significantly different after spinal anaesthesia, before treatment and 15 minutes after treatment, between the groups.
|Figure 1: Showing incidence of side effects, nausea, vomiting, sedation and headache, which were more common in the tramadol group and less common in the clonidine group|
Click here to view
| Discussion|| |
The results of this study indicate that the response rate is less and the time taken to control shivering is longer, but the side effects are fewer in the clonidine group. The response rate is better and time taken to control shivering shorter in the tramadol group, but with more side effects. Shivering occurs as a thermoregulatory response to hypothermia or muscle hyperactivity with clonic or tonic patterns and different frequencies have been reported. However, in the post spinal period shivering has been reported in patients with normothermia, suggesting that other mechanisms, other than heat loss and subsequent decrease in core body temperature may contribute to the development of shivering.  These mechanisms include inhibited spinal reflexes, apprehension, decreased sympathetic activity, pyrogen release, adrenal gland suppression and respiratory alkalosis.
Hypothermia during central neuraxial blockade is common,  and can be nearly as severe as that observed during general anaesthesia.  There are three principal reasons for hypothermia under spinal anaesthesia. First, spinal anaesthesia leads to an internal redistribution of heat from the core to the peripheral compartment,  secondary to sympathetic block and peripheral vasodilatation. Second, loss of thermoregulatory vasoconstriction below the level of the spinal block, leads to increased heat loss from the body surfaces. Last, there is altered thermoregulation under the central neuraxial block, characterized by a decrease in shivering thresholds. In addition rapid administration of cold intravenous fluids contributes to the development of shivering.
Treatment modalities include covering the patient with blankets, application of radiant heat and warming the operating room.  The use of warm local anaesthetic solution or warm intravenous fluids has met with various degrees of success.  Various pharmacological treatments like i.v. opioids, alfentanil, pethidine;  nalbuphine and meperidine,  non-opioid analgesic tramadol,  5-HT3 antagonists;  ondansetron,  dolasetron; and cholinomimetic agent physostigmine  have been used; however, side effects like hypotension, hypertension, sedation, respiratory depression, nausea and vomiting, limit their use. Our study was designed to compare a small dose (50 μg) of clonidine, an α2 adrenoceptor agonist, with that of tramadol a non-opioid analgesic for control of shivering during spinal anaesthesia.
Clonidine is an α2 adrenoceptor agonist, with antihypertensive, sedative, analgesic and anti-shivering properties. The anti-shivering effects of alpha (α) adrenoceptor agonists are mediated by binding to α2 receptors mainly the α2b receptors that mediate vasoconstriction and the anti-shivering effect.  In addition clonidine has hypothalamic thermoregulatory effects,  as it may exert an inhibitory action on the hypothalamus, by decreasing the nor-adrenaline synaptic release through α2 receptors located at the pre-synaptic nerve terminals, thus contributing to its anti-shivering effect. 
Tramadol has been used as an analgesic for postoperative pain and labor analgesia without any adverse effects on the mother or baby.  It has been shown to be effective in controlling post spinal shivering.  Tramadol has got agonist properties on opioid receptors, with the main opioid effect being mediated through μ receptors, with minimal effect on κ (kappa) and σ (Sigma) receptors. It activates the monoaminergic receptors of the descending spinal inhibitory pathway of pain. It also inhibits the synaptosomal nor-adrenaline and serotonin uptake and may also contribute to its analgesic effect. In our study both clonidine and tramadol controlled shivering at doses of 1 μg and 1 mg per kg respectively, although better control was observed with tramadol. However, the incidences of side effects were more with tramadol than with clonidine.
| Conclusion|| |
Clonidine 50 μg is less effective than Tramadol 50 mg, in the treatment of post spinal shivering. However, the side effects were fewer with clonidine, but were significantly high with tramadol. Our study has limitations of small sample size, hence, further controlled large sample-sized studies with different doses of clonidine are required to confirm the optimal dose and the results of this study.
| References|| |
|1.||Ozaki M, Kurz A, Sessler DI, Lenhardt R, Schroeder M, Moayeri A, et al. Thermoregulatory thresholds during spinal and epidural Anaesthesia. Anesthesiology 1994;81:282-8. |
|2.||Jeon YT, Jeon YS, Kim YC, Bahk JH, Do SH, Lim YJ. Intrathecal clonidine does not reduce post-spinal shivering. Acta Anesthesiol Scand 2005;49:1509-13. |
|3.||Kurz A, Sessler DI, Narzt E, Bekar A, Lenhardt R, Huemer G, et al. Postoperative hemodynamic and thermoregulatory consequences of intraoperative core hypothermia. J Clin Anesth 1995;7:359-66. |
|4.||Glosten B, Hynson J, Sessler DI, McGuire J. Preanaesthetic skin-surface warming reduces redistribution hypothermia caused by epidural block. Anesth Analg 1993;77:488-93. |
|5.||Chan AM, Ng KF, Tong EW, Jan GS. Control of shivering under regional Anaesthesia in obstetric patients with tramadol. Can J Anesth 1999;46:253-8. |
|6.||Capogna G, Celleno D. IV clonidine for post-extradural shivering in parturients: A preliminary study. Br J Anesth 1993;71:294-5. |
|7.||Tsai YC, Chu KS. A comparison of tramadol, amitriptyline, and meperidine for postepidural anaesthetic shivering in parturients. Anesth Analg 2001;93:1288-92. |
|8.||Wilson E, David A, MacKenzie N, Grant IS. Sedation during spinal Anaesthesia: Comparison of propofol and midazolam. Br J Anesth 1990;64:48-52 |
|9.||Horn EP, Sessler DI, Standl T, Schroeder F, Bartz HJ, Beyer JC, et al. Non-thermoregulatory shivering in patients recovering from isoflurane or desflurane Anaesthesia. Anesthesiology 1998;89:878-86. |
|10.||Hendolin H, Länsimies E. Skin and central temperatures during continuous epidural analgesia and general Anaesthesia in patients subjected to open prostatectomy. Ann Clin Res 1982;14:181-6. |
|11.||Frank SM, Beattie C, Christopherson R, Norris EJ, Rock P, Parker S, et al. Epidural versus general anaesthesia, ambient operating room temperature, and patient age as predictors of inadvertent hypothermia. Anesthesiology 1992;77:252-7. |
|12.||Matsukawa T, Sessler DI, Christensen R, Ozaki M, Schroeder M. Heat flow and distribution during epidural anaesthesia. Anesthesiology 1995;83:961-7. |
|13.||Chamberlain DP, Chamberlain BD. Changes in the skin temperature of the trunk and their relationship to sympathetic blocked during spinal anaesthesia. Anesthesiology 1986;65:139-43. |
|14.||Walmsley AJ, Giesecke AH, Lipton JM. Contribution of extradural temperature to shivering during extradural anaesthesia. Br J Anesth 1986;58:1130-4. |
|15.||Wrench IJ, Cavill G, Ward JE, Crossley AW. Comparison between alfentanil, pethidine and placebo in the treatment of postAnaesthetic shiveri n g. Br J Anesth 1997;79:541-2. |
|16.||Wang JJ, Ho ST, Lee SC, Liu YC. A comparison among nalbuphine, meperidine and placebo for treating postanaesthetic shivering. Anesth Analg 1999;88:686-9. |
|17.||deWitte J, Deloof T, deVeylder J, Housmans PR. Tramadol in the treatment of postanaesthetic shivering. Acta Anesthesiol Scand 1997 ; 41:506-10. |
|18.||Powell RM, Buggy DJ. Ondansetron given before induction of anaesthesia reduces shivering after general anaesthesia. Anesth Analg 2000;90:1423-7. |
|19.||Bock M, Sinner B, Göttlicher M, Simon E, Martin E, Motsch J. Involvement of serotonergic pathways in postAnaesthetic cold defence: Dolasetron prevents shivering. J Therm Biol 2002;27:159-66. |
|20.||Horn EP, Standl T, Sessler DI, von Knobelsdorff G, Büchs C, Schulte am Esch J, et al. Physostigmine prevents postanaesthetic shivering as does meperidine or clonidine. Anesthesiology 1998;88:108-13. |
|21.||Kamibayashi T, Maze M. Clinical uses of alpha2- adrenergic agonists. Anesthesiology 2000;93:1345-9. |
|22.||Tewari A, Katyal S, Singh A, Garg S, Kaul TK, Narula N. Prophylaxis with oral clonidine prevents perioperative shivering in patients undergoing transurethral resection of prostate under subarachnoid blockade. Indian J Urol 2006;22:208-12. |
|23.||Shen KZ, Surprenant A. Mechanism underlying presynaptic inhibition through α2- adrenoceptors in guinea-pig submucosal neurons. J Physiol 1990;431:609-28. |
|24.||Viegas OA, Khaw B, Rathnam SS. Tramadol in labour pain primiparous patient. A Prospective comparative clinical trial. Eur J Obstet Gynaecol Reprod Biol 1993;49:131-5. |
|25.||Pausawasdi S, Jirasirithum S, Phanarai C. The use of tramadol hydrochloride in the treatment of post anaesthestic shivering. J Med Assoc Thai 1990;73:16-20. |
|26.||Lee CR, McTavish D, Sorkin EM. Tramadol: A Preliminary Review of its Pharmacodynamic and Pharmacokinetic Properties, and Therapeutic Potential in Acute and Chronic Pain States. Drugs 1993;46:313-40. |
[Table 1], [Table 2]